| The Employment Act (H.R.
2202,
S. 380, 15 USC
§ 1021 et seq.) is a
United States federal law.
Its main purpose was to lay the responsibility of economic
stability onto the federal government.
By the end of
World War II, the nation
was finally shrugging free of the drastic economic
recession that had
culminated in the
Great Depression. During
that time, unemployment rates soared into the twenties of
percent, and only radical government spending seemed to curb
further degradation. The
U.S. Congress, fearful of
another bout of unemployment spurred by the return of
discharged war veterans, sought to establish preemptive
safeguards against economic downturn.
The United States relied on Keynesian economic theory to
develop its strategy. The theory, set forth by economist
John Maynard Keynes,
contends that unemployment is caused by insufficient
aggregate demand relative to the possible aggregate supply
generated by full employment. Swings in aggregate demand
create a phenomenon known as a business cycle that leads to
irregular downsizing and hiring runs, causing fluctuations
in unemployment. Keynes argued that the biggest contributor
of these shifts in aggregate demand is investment.
To keep aggregate demand fairly consistent and thus
minimize the impact of business cycles, the government must
keep the rate of investment reasonably constant. To this
effect, the government should engage in compensatory
spending to counterbalance private sector investment,
minimizing its indirect effect on unemployment.
The original bill, called the Full Employment Bill of
1946, was introduced in the House as H.R. 2202 and
introduced without change by Congressman
Wright Patman in the Senate
as S. 380. The bill represented a concerted effort to
develop a broad economic policy for the country. In
particular, it mandated that the federal government do
everything in its authority to achieve full employment,
which was established as a right guaranteed to the American
people. In this vein, the bill required the President to
submit an annual economic report in addition to the national
budget. The report, designated the Economic Report of
President, must estimate the projected employment rate for
the next fiscal year, and if not commensurate with the full
employment rate, to mandate policies as necessary to attain
it.
There was strong opposition to the wording of the bill.
In particular, a number of congressmen argued that business
cycles in a
free enterprise economy
were natural and that compensatory spending should only be
exercised in the most extreme of cases. Some also believed
that the economy would naturally drive toward full
employment levels. Others believed that accurate employment
level forecasting by the government was not practical or
feasible. Some were uncomfortable with an outright guarantee
of employment.
The bill was pressured to take on a number of amendments
that forced the removal of the guarantee of full employment
and the order to engage in compensatory spending. Although
the spirit of the bill carried through into the Employment
Act of 1946 (hereafter referred to as "Act"), its
metaphorical bite was gone. The final Act was not so much a
mandate as it was a set of suggestions.
President
Harry S. Truman signed the
compromise bill into law on
February 20,
1946.
The Employment Act of 1946 was a definitive attempt by
the federal government to develop macroeconomic policy.
Future economic policy was allowed to grow beyond the
constitutionally defined
realm of monetary and trade control and into the national
economy at-large. Although Congress removed all of the
quantitative markers from the final incarnation of the law,
the Act keeps the original spirit intact and encourages the
federal government to "promote maximum employment,
production, and purchasing power." This clause set the
foundations for future cooperation and communication between
the federal government and private enterprise.
The Act requires the President to submit an annual
economic report within ten days of the submission of the
national budget that forecasts the future state of the
economy, including employment, production, capital
formation, and real income statistics. This
Economic Report of the President,
as the Act names it, sets forth future economic goals of the
country and offers suggestions on how to attain it, a marked
compromise from the original bill's focus on compensatory
spending.
The Act creates the
Council of Economic Advisers,
an appointed advisory board that will advise and assist the
President in formulating economic policy. It also creates
the
Joint Economic Committee, a
committee composed of both senators and representatives
instructed to review the government's economic policy at
least annually.
Unemployment levels remained fairly steady after the
passing of the Act. After 1970, however, the economy began
to fluctuate and unemployment rates rose again. The same
fears that motivated the creation of the Act in 1946
precipitated an amendment in 1978, entitled the
Full Employment and Balanced Growth
Act. Some Congressmen, dissatisfied with
the vague wording of this act, sought to modify the Act in a
way that would strengthen and clarify the country's economic
policy.
As before, Congress turned to
Keynesian economic theory
for a solution, which emphasized economic control through
manipulation of demand-side factors. In particular, the
government can minimize the shock of business fluctuations
by compensatory spending, essentially inserting
government investment money where private money used to be.
Furthermore, Congress encouraged the government to develop a
sound
monetary policy,
controlling inflation and pushing toward full employment by
managing the amount and liquidity of currency in
circulation. As a last resort, Congress believed that
unemployment could be temporarily relieved by the creation
of government jobs as they did during the
Great Depression.
Finally, Congress sought to involve more elements of the
federal government in the economic policy process, and to
clarify the role of those elements that were already
involved. In particular, the central bank of the United
States, the
Federal Reserve, and the
Presidency.
Representative
Augustus Hawkins and
Senator
Hubert Humphrey created the
Full Employment and Balanced Growth Act. It was signed into
law by President
Jimmy Carter on
October 27,
1978, and codified as 15
USC
§ 3101.
The Act explicitly instructs the nation to strive toward
four ultimate goals: full employment, growth in production,
price stability, and balance of trade and budget. By
explicitly setting requirements and goals for the federal
government to attain, the Act is markedly stronger than its
predecessor. In brief, the Act:
- Explicitly states that the federal government will
rely primarily on private enterprise to achieve the four
goals.
- Instructs the government to take reasonable means to
balance the budget.
- Instructs the government to establish a
balance of trade,
avoiding harmful trade deficits.
- Mandates the Board of Governors of the Federal
Reserve to establish a monetary policy that maintains
long-run growth, minimizes inflation, and promotes price
stability.
- Instructs the Board of Governors of the Federal
Reserve to transmit an
Monetary Policy Report to the
Congress twice a year outlining its monetary
policy.
- Requires the President to set numerical goals for
the economy of the next fiscal year in the
Economic Report of the President
and to suggest policies that will achieve these goals.
- Requires the Chairman of the Federal Reserve to
connect the monetary policy with the Presidential
economic policy.
The Act set specific numerical goals for the President to
attain. By 1983, unemployment rates should be not more than
3% for persons aged 20 or over and not more than 4% for
persons aged 16 or over, and inflation rates should not be
over 4%. By 1988, inflation rates should be 0%. The Act
allows Congress to revise these goals as time progresses.
If private enterprise is lacking in power to achieve
these goals, the Act expressly allows the government to
create a "reservoir of public employment." These jobs are
required to be in the lower ranges of skill and pay so as to
not draw the workforce away from the private sector.
Perhaps most interestingly, the Act directly prohibits
discrimination on account
of gender, religion, race, age, and national origin in any
program created under the Act.
|