![]() |
![]() |
![]() |
![]() |
| KARL MARX | JOHN KENNETH GALBRAITH | MILTON FRIEDMAN | ADAM SMITH |
| DAS KAPITAL, 1867 | THE AFFLUENT SOCIETY, 1958 | FREE TO CHOOSE, 1980 | THE WEALTH OF NATIONS, 1776 |
| SOCIALISTS | LIBERALS | CONSERVATIVES | CAPITALISTS |
| CAPITALISM SELF-INTEREST PRIVATE PROPERTY FREEDOM OF CHOICE COMPETITIVE MARKETS NO GOVERNMENT INTERVENTION |
|||
| WEALTH = UTILITY LABOR CREATES VALUE PROFIT IS SURPLUS LABOR |
WEALTH = GOODS INVESTMENT CREATES VALUE PROFIT IS RETURN FOR RISK |
||
| FLAWS OF
CAPITALISM: EXTERNALITIES MONOPOLIES INEQUITY PUBLIC GOODS BUSINESS CYCLES ASYMMETRIC INFORMATION |
NO PROBLEM: FREE MARKETS ARE COMPLETELY SELF-CORRECTING ![]() |
||
| SOLUTION: COMPLETE PUBLIC OWNERSHIP OF THE MEANS OF PRODUCTION ![]() SOCIALISM (which eventually leads to COMMUNISM) |
MOST
MODERN ECONOMISTS AGREE THE GOVERNMENT SHOULD BE RESPONSIBLE FOR: PROVIDING A LEGAL FRAMEWORK MAINTAINING COMPETITION CORRECTING FOR EXTERNALITIES REDISTRIBUTING INCOME PROVIDING PUBLIC GOODS |
||
| SOLUTION: DIRECT GOVERNMENT INTERVENTION ![]() GOVERNMENT AS REFEREE |
FLAWS OF
SOCIALISM: RATIONAL IGNORANCE SPECIAL INTERESTS SHORT-TERM THINKING BUREAUCRATIC CAPTURE DEADWEIGHT LOSS |
||
| SOLUTION: INDIRECT GOVERNMENT INTERVENTION ![]() GOVERNMENT AS REPAIRMAN |
|||
| EXAMPLE: CIGARETTES EXTERNAL COST Lung Cancer, Second-hand Smoke PUBLIC GOOD: Better Health for Everyone ASYMMETRIC INFORMATION: Ammonia Added to Nicotine to Create Greater Addictive Properties MONOPOLY POWER: Two Tobacco Companies Control 80% of the Market |
|||
| SOLUTION | |||
| GOVERNMENT SHUTS DOWN TOBACCO FARMS AND CIGARETTE FACTORIES | GOVERNMENT TAXES CIGARETTES, AND BANS SMOKING FOR EVERYONE UNDER 18 | GOVERNMENT PUTS WARNING LABELS ON CIGARETTES; LAWYERS CAN SUE TOBACCO COMPANIES | LET EVERY INDIVIDUAL DECIDE FOR HIMSELF |