BY
LENNOX SAMUELS
The Dallas Morning News
MEXICO CITY
- Last year, a member of
Mexico City's legislature was videotaped accepting a bribe.
The brother of a former president is widely assumed to have
built a $100 million fortune through influence peddling. In
1997, the head of the country's drug interdiction office was
dismissed - for involvement in drug trafficking.
Those and other examples illustrate
the perennial stigma of Mexico, considered one of the most
corrupt countries in the hemisphere. The recent furor over a
video in which four enforcers for the Gulf cartel are
interrogated and one is executed has sharply refocused
attention on corruption.
The men on the video suggested
links between drug traffickers and the government, and
authorities have conceded that federal law enforcement
officials and perhaps current or former members of the
military may have been involved in torturing the four men
and making the video.
The videotaped allegations are a
reminder, analysts say, that in Mexico corruption not only
is a disease that afflicts government and public officials,
but also a national pathology.
And, some add, corruption is so
deeply embedded in the society that there's no prospect of
eliminating or even curbing it anytime soon.
"Unfortunately, corruption seems to
be part of our DNA," said political analyst Jorge Chabat.
"What we have discovered ... is
that this is not endemic," said Eduardo A. Bohorquez,
executive secretary of Transparencia Mexicana, or Mexican
Transparency. "It's more epidemic."
For Bohorquez, whose agency
measures corruption in Mexico, "Corruption is the abuse of
the public trust to gain a private benefit. You take a
mandate from a public group and act on your own behalf."
But other experts say the problem
goes far beyond that, extending from the ordinary citizen to
high reaches of government. They say most Mexicans have
become accustomed to paying bribes and to the notion that
the average police officer will try to shake them down in
some way.
Children are told from an early age
that they should not trust authorities - including the
police, experts say.
"My instinct is that it is deeply
learned sitting at the table listening to one's parents,"
said John Bailey, a Georgetown University professor. "Police
are there to be avoided." Bailey said many Mexicans regard
bribery as standard operating procedure. Further, he and
others say, police officers assume they are expected to use
extortion to augment their salaries, which are generally
low.
Gabriel and Mayela, a Guadalajara
couple who declined to give their last names, insist they
want "a new Mexico" without corruption. Asked, however, if
they have ever paid a bribe, they reluctantly said yes.
"Of course I have, but that doesn't
mean I'm corrupt. I'm just practical," Gabriel said.
Added Mayela: "You get nowhere
trying to play by the rules. You only go crazy because you
run into so many walls."
Such responses are instructive,
experts say.
"If I live in a society where to
advance myself I have to be corrupt, I probably would change
my behavior," said Dr. David A. Shirk, director of the
Trans-Border Institute at the University of California-San
Diego. "In Mexico, the rules are such that people can thrive
by using corrupt behavior."
But Shirk said he does not believe
corruption is somehow part of Mexico's collective psyche.
"As a political scientist, I have a
hard time saying people are more corrupt because they're
Mexican or grew up a certain way.
"That's disproved by the fact that
Mexicans who go to another country behave the way the laws
and rules of that country dictate. We have 20 million
Mexicans in the U.S., and I don't think they're bribing the
police."
Shirk said many Mexican police
officers earn $300-$600 a month. That compares with
officers' annual salaries of about $55,000 in Chula Vista,
one of the southernmost cities in California.
"That to me shows the investment we
are willing to make in a professional police force," he
said. "It's not just giving a guy a gun and a badge and
saying, 'Go out and do a good job.'"
In Mexico, the poor salaries are
compounded by the poor examples set by top officials,
including law enforcement leaders, analysts say.
A former drug czar, Gen. Jesus
Gutierrez Rebollo, was sentenced to more than 70 years in
prison in 1997 for working for the late leader of the Juarez
cartel, Amado Carrillo Fuentes.
Last year, video images showed
Mexico City legislator Rene Bejarano Martinez of the Party
of the Democratic Revolution receiving $45,000 from
businessman Carlos Ahumada Kurtz. The legislator denied the
money was for doing favors for Ahumada. Bejarano spent eight
months in jail.
Raul Salinas de Gortari, brother of
former president Carlos Salinas de Gortari and who was
jailed for 10 years on a murder charge before being
exonerated, was accused of receiving millions of dollars for
influence peddling and stashing the money overseas. He has
not been convicted of any crime related to the money.
Some analysts say the 71-year reign
of the PRI, the Institutional Revolutionary Party, was
largely responsible for creating an atmosphere of impunity
and for cementing Mexico's culture of corruption.
"In Mexico, certain interests
colluded to maintain power through the PRI," Shirk said.
"There was no accountability to the governed by the
government. In the PRI, when your successor was going to be
from your own party you could steal with impunity."
When President Vicente Fox of the
National Action Party, or PAN, finally ousted the PRI in
2000, some were hopeful that corruption would decline.
In March, Fox declared that his
administration was in a "head-on battle against corruption."
"Together, we work for a Mexico
full of justice, legality and democratic opportunities," the
president said.
But the latest measurement of
corruption by Berlin-based Transparency International found
that 50 percent of Mexicans remain pessimistic about
corruption and believe it will get worse.
The 2005 survey, released Dec. 9,
showed that Mexico was one of the top four countries (along
with Cameroon, Paraguay and Cambodia), where the largest
number of respondents - between 31 percent and 45 percent -
answered yes when asked if they or someone in their family
had paid any kind of bribe in the last 12 months.
A majority of the Mexicans told
pollsters the bribes had been directly solicited by
authorities.
"In Mexico, corruption does not
have a party," said writer and political commentator Homero
Aridjis. "It's the same with the PRI, the PAN and the PRD.
"I grew up with the PRI and looked
forward to the end of corruption with a different party in
power. But is does not matter. For people like me it's a
moral collapse."
This year, Arturo Montiel, who was
seeking to become the PRI's presidential candidate in 2006,
withdrew from the race after media reports revealed that he
owned half a dozen expensive real estate properties,
including a $2.1 million apartment in Paris. Party officials
later said an investigation was not warranted because he
could have earned the money during his tenure as governor of
the State of Mexico.
But an analysis by the Mexico City
newspaper, Reforma, showed that Montiel could not have
earned enough money as governor to pay for the properties.
That's similar to what occurred in
the Jose Lopez Portillo administration (1976-82), Aridjis
said. "That was the epitome of corruption. The country
almost collapsed under the weight of corruption. They built
the Parthenon of corruption with a terrible chief of police,
Arturo Durazo Moreno.
"And when they accused him of
getting rich from corruption, he said he got the money from
his savings."
Bailey said he does not believe the
rule of law is very important in Mexico.
"Socialization about the law is
pretty negative," he said. "Learning about the law and the
government is pretty negative. The lesson is how to deal
with the law pragmatically - how to avoid the law."
Analysts said Mexicans cannot look
to their elected leaders to change the country's culture of
corruption. Civil society must take responsibility, they
say. Several maintain that the legal and judicial system
must change to make everyone - especially police -
accountable.
James Cooper, assistant dean at
California Western School of Law in San Diego, is
spearheading a program, Proyecto Acceso, to reform judicial
systems in Latin America.
He said the program has seen
considerable success in Chile and that his team has been
encouraged by the reception in Mexico from Fox's office.
"That's where the change has to
take place," he said.
Chabat, the political analyst,
added: "The legal system is very complicated, cumbersome and
slow. They say, 'You need a few honorable men.' But we have
a structural problem. Even with evidence of say, police
corruption, it is difficult to prove. We have impunity. Even
if you have a decent attorney general, as we do now, he has
limited instruments, few tools to fight corruption.
"We have to change the law and get
a more efficient judicial system." |