Country |
BRITAIN | The European Union | SOVIET UNION | RUSSIA | CHINA | NIGERIA | Mexico | Iran | |
![]() |
Non-written :Acts of Parliament and tradition Legitimacy: |
ESCC: Paris 1951 Legitimacy: Constitution? |
Constitutions: Legitimacy: Marxism-Leninism |
1993 Yeltsin Constitution Legitimacy: |
The Common Program 1949 Constitutions: Legitimacy: Marxism-Leninism-Maoism |
Constitutions: Legitimacy: Military |
1917 Constitution Legitimacy: Sonoran Mediation no re-election |
1979 Constitution Legitimacy: Islam |
|
![]() |
Unitary Parliamentary Structure: |
Structure: Presidential/ Structure: |
Structure: Authoritarian One-party State |
Structure: Presidential/ Structure: |
Unitary Authoritarian One-party State |
Federal
Presidential system designed to replace the dysfunctional post-independence parliamentary model Bicameral |
Federal Presidential Bicameral |
Unitary Presidential Bicameral Theocracy supervised by Islamic Authorities |
|
![]() |
![]() |
Monarch Structure: |
President European Commission 1 member from each country nominated by home nation approved by Council 5 year terms swear allegiance to Europe supervises EU bureaucracy puts new policy proposals on Council's agenda |
Structure:
|
President 2 six-year terms Direct vote with Majority, 2 rounds unless 51% Nominates PM, Chairs Cabinet Chief policymaker Foreign Policy appoints regional governors Rule by decree during declared state of emergency Veto power Nominates heads of bureaucracy, judges |
Structure: President
|
President Direct vote: must receive both a majority of popular vote and 25% of the vote in at least 12 states (as an attempt to lessen the impact of regionalism) Supreme Military Council or Federal Executive Council |
President
sexenio directly elected with plurality appoints the cabinet with the approval of the Senate no vice-president Presidential powers have weakened since 1980s
|
Structure: President 2 four year terms direct election with run-off for top 2 candidates
appointed for life--with annual review--by the Assembly of Experts veto power over all policies and appointments |
![]() |
Prime Minister serves at discretion of majority party in Commons Dominant policy-maker Cabinet |
Premier Presidium and the Council of Ministers
|
Prime Minister serves at the discretion of the President Nominated by President, approved by Duma; 3X rejection requires dissolution Cabinet members may report directly to President Cabinet may not reflect party strengths incompatibility clause State governors appointed by President; regional legislatures subordinate to Federal government through revenue distribution State Council members of governors of regions and speakers of regional legislatures meet directly with the President once every three months |
Premier State Council serve 5 year terms nominated by National Party Congress; approved by National People's Congress |
President predominates over other constitutional powers Control of federal bureaucracy (appointments, retirements; large opportunities for establishing patron-client relations) State governors with unicameral legislatures subordinate to Federal government through oil revenue distribution |
President Control of federal bureaucracy and para-statal (semi-autonomous institutions) appointments State governors are elected for six years; each state has a local legislature and has the right to levy state-wide taxes; municipal presidents are elected every three years state governors and local mayors appoint state bureaucracy |
Elected: President appoints and supervises cabinet--8 vice-presidents and 22 members--as well as local administrators with approval of Majlis and Assembly of Experts puts policy proposals to Majlis local elected councils under supervision of appointed mayor or governor and religious authorities Unelected: Council of Guardians 12 members |
||
![]() |
![]() |
House of Lords 700 members Symbolic power Lords may participate in Cabinet Scrutinizes, delays legislation Final Court of Appeal |
Council of the EU represents national governments; representation scheduled by COREPER rotating presidency initiates all legislation (directives) qualified majority voting: population and wealth unanimous vote to overturn rejection by Parliament |
Structure: Supreme Soviet (representation from regional and local soviets)
Politburo Central Committee of CPSU |
Federation Council 178 members no formal political parties are allowed indirect appointment: formerly governors of regions and speakers of regional legislatures appointed themselves to these seats; current law forbids holding dual offices approves legislation, but negative vote can be overridden by lower house with simple majority Confirms state of emergency |
Structure: National People's Congress (3000 representatives from regional and local congresses)
Standing Committee of the Politburo Central Committee of CCP |
Senate 109 members increased number of states aims at guaranteeing representation to smaller ethnic groups reflects tensions between the central government and the states |
Senate
128-members 96 seats are elected on a first-past-the-post basis, and 32 nationally by proportional representation |
Assembly of Experts 86 members national list all candidates must be approved by the Guardian Council appoints and reconfirms Rahbar reviews, amends, approves, vetoes legislation from Majlis |
|
House of Commons 659 members term at discretion of Prime Minister FPTP plurality elections from party list; no residence requirement Sovereign policy-making power Vote of No Confidence |
European Parliament 732 members directly elected to 5 year terms |
Duma 450 members term at discretion of Prime Minister, President was 1/2 proportional from 2 round run-off party list with 5% cutoff; 1/2 FPTP
from districts Initiates and approves legislation overrules upper house with simple majority Vote of No Confidence |
House of Representatives 360 members Tradition of inefficiency and corruption (patron-client relations; regional interests prevail over national priorities) |
Chamber of
Deputies
500-members 300 seats are elected on a first-past-the-post basis and 200 by proportional representation |
Majlis 290 members multi-member constituency voting with 25% minimum requirement all candidates must be approved by the Guardian Council reviews, amends, votes on legislation proposed by the President which must then be approved by the Upper House, the Council of Guardians, and the Rahbar |
|||
![]() |
House of Lords Common Law Cannot override acts of Parliament Conservative ex-post facto privilege of Prime Minister |
European Court of Justice -one member appointed by each member country for up to 3 6-year terms Courts of First Instance Court of Auditors |
Under the control of the Executive State Prosecutor; show Trials People's Courts Gulags |
Supreme Court 19 judges appointed for life by President with approval of Senate Civil Code Constitutional Court Arbitrates between Legislative and Executive |
Supreme People's Court Under the control of the Executive attempted creation of Civil Code system State Prosecutor; show Trials People's Courts Xia-feng |
U.S.-inspired independent judiciary Common Law Supreme Court can, in theory, challenge the Executive. In practice, it has not |
U.S.-inspired independent judiciary Civil Code system There are 68 district courts and a series of appellate courts with a Supreme Court; federal legal system, with states enjoying significant authority amparos |
Public Court System Supreme Court; appeals
Revolutionary Court system Clerical Court system Shari'a all courts appointed and supervised by Rahbar |
|
![]() |
Examinations and Elite Educational Institutions Specialized Insulated from politics resist policy initiatives QUANGOs |
COREPER EU Bureaucracy |
Secretariat Cooption through Nomenklatura Self-serving Patron-client Corrupt |
Power Ministries Nomenklatura "shock treatment"
|
Secretariat Cooption through Nomenklatura Self-serving Patron-client Corrupt |
Lack of experience; poorly trained Bureaucratic recruitment based on ethnicity Foreign presence (currently, IMF officials in Central Bank) |
Federal Election Commission large opportunities for establishing patron-client relations at local, state, and federal levels
|
highly educated professional bureaucracy increasingly subject to
the clergy Expediency Council Military Revolutionary Guard all are appointed by and responsible to the Rahbar |
|
![]() |
Labour Conservative Liberal Democratic Alliance |
European People's Party European Democrats Party of European Socialists |
Communist Party of the Soviet Union |
United Russia Party Communist Party of the Russian Federation Rodina Liberal Democratic Party Yabloko Union of Right Forces |
Chinese Communist Party 'Red' vs 'Expert' factionalism |
Multi-party system (affiliation mostly determined along ethnic and religious lines)
PDP ANPP APGA |
PAN PRI PRD |
no official party affiliation is allowed in political campaigns,
but factionalism remains: Second of Khordad Servants of the Reconstruction Followers of the Imam |
|
![]() |
consociational groups: TUC CBI |
intelligensia |
oligarchs siloviki nomenklatura military youth movements disorganized pluralist organizations |
PLA CAC CMC Falun Gong Student Democracy Movement rising wealthy class Communist Youth League Fifth and Sixth generation of Leadership |
The Military Dominated by Northern groups (Hausa-Fulani) Despite internal divisions, it is the most cohesive political group in Nigeria Dominated by patron-client relations between higher and lower ranking officials |
increasing lobbying with strengthening of
legislature CTM CNC CNOP Zapatisitas |
City Mosques autonomous semi-public institutionssuch as the Foundation of the Oppressed the Liberation Movement the National Front the Tudeh Worker's House/Islamic Labor Party Office of Student Solidarity Islamic Women's Association |
||
![]() |
European Union immigration constitutional reform Northern Ireland |
deepening and
broadening immigration |
"vertical power" relationship with former Soviet countries Chechnya corruption and criminal violence oligarchs |
agricultural reform corruption income inequity Taiwan Market-Leninism growing nationalism |
Dispute of Sharia--fundamentalist Islamic law in North
Rampant corruption inequitable distribution of oil revenue |
corruption Chiapas emigration/border control with United States income inequity |
international pressures from national security issues gender equality demographic issues: age |
||
![]() |
Tony Blair Gordon Brown David Cameron Lord Mandelson
|
Valéry Giscard d'Estaing Nicholas Sarkozy Dominique de Villepin Segolene Royal
|
Vladimir Putin Dmitri Medvedev Yuri Luzkhov Vladimir Zhirinovsky |
Jiang Zemin Hu Jintao Wen Jiabao Xi Jinping |
Olesegun Obasanjo Muhammadu Buhari Chukwuemeka Ojukwu Atiku Abubakar Ibrahim Babangida |
Andre Obrador Felipe Calderon Roberto Madrazo Commandante Zero |
Grand Ayatollah Ali Khameini Mahmoud Ahmadinejad Imam Mohammad KhatamiAyatollah Hashemi Rafsanjani Ayatollah Ahmad Jannati |