Country

BRITAIN The European Union SOVIET UNION RUSSIA CHINA NIGERIA Mexico Iran
CONSTITUTION

Non-written:
Acts of Parliament and tradition

Legitimacy:
Gradual evolution of Absolute Monarchy into Constitutional Monarchy

ESCC: Paris 1951
EEC: Rome 1957
EC: CAP-EMS-COREPER 1967
EU: Maastricht 1991

Legitimacy:
Gradual evolution and expansion through treaties

Constitution?

Constitutions:
1918, 1924, 1936, and 1977

Legitimacy:
Revolution 1917

Marxism-Leninism

1993 Yeltsin Constitution

Legitimacy:
Designed to guarantee citizen's civil rights through consent of the governed, referendum

The Common Program 1949

Constitutions:
1954, 1975, 1978, and 1982

Legitimacy:
Revolution 1949

Marxism-Leninism-Maoism

Constitutions:
1960, 1963, 1979, 1989, and 1999

Legitimacy:
Independence 1959

Military

1917 Constitution

Legitimacy:
Revolution 1910

Sonoran Mediation

no re-election

1979 Constitution

Legitimacy:
Revolution 1979

Islam

SYSTEM

Unitary
(devolution)

Parliamentary

Structure:
Bicameral
Function: Unicameral

Structure:
Confederal

Presidential/
Parliamentary

Structure:
Bicameral
Function:
Unicameral

Structure:
Federal
Function:
Unitary

Authoritarian One-party State

Structure:
Federal
Function
Unitary
(President oversees Regional Representatives)

Presidential/
Parliamentary

Structure:
Bicameral
Function
Unicameral

Unitary

Authoritarian One-party State

Federal

Presidential system designed to replace the dysfunctional post-independence parliamentary model

Bicameral

Federal

Presidential

Bicameral

Unitary

Presidential

Bicameral

Theocracy supervised by Islamic Authorities

EXECUTIVE STATE

Monarch

Structure:
Appoints PM, calls elections
Function:
Symbol of the Nation
, Unity of the Commonwealth, Head of the Anglican Church

President
 

European Commission

1 member from each country nominated by home nation approved by Council

5 year terms

swear allegiance to Europe

supervises EU bureaucracy

puts new policy proposals on Council's agenda

Structure:
President


Function:
General-Secretary of the CPSU

President

2 six-year terms
(changed in 2007 from 4 year terms)

Direct vote with Majority, 2 rounds unless 51%

Nominates PM, Chairs Cabinet
Dissolves Parliament

Chief policymaker

Foreign Policy

appoints regional governors

Rule by decree during declared state of emergency

Veto power

Nominates heads of bureaucracy, judges

Structure:
President


Function:
Chairman/General-Secretary of the CCP

President

Direct vote:  must receive both a majority of popular vote and 25% of the vote in at least 12 states (as an attempt to lessen the impact of regionalism)

Supreme Military Council or Federal Executive Council
(during Military rule)

President

sexenio
(single six-year term)

directly elected with plurality

appoints the cabinet with the approval of the Senate

no vice-president

Presidential powers have weakened since 1980s

 

Structure:
President

2 four year terms

direct election with run-off for top 2 candidates


Function:
Rahbar
(Grand Ayatollah)Supreme Spiritual Leader

appointed for life--with annual review--by the Assembly of Experts

veto power over all policies and appointments

GOVERNMENT

Prime Minister

serves at discretion of majority party in Commons

Dominant policy-maker
(more powerful than the House of Commons?)

Cabinet
(Political, not technical)

Premier

Presidium and the Council of Ministers

 

Prime Minister

serves at the discretion of the President

Nominated by President, approved by Duma; 3X rejection requires dissolution

Cabinet members may report directly to President

Cabinet may not reflect party strengths

incompatibility clause

State governors appointed by President; regional legislatures subordinate to Federal government through revenue distribution
State Council
members of governors of regions and speakers of regional legislatures meet directly with the President once every three months

Premier

State Council

serve 5 year terms

nominated by National Party Congress; approved by National People's Congress

President predominates over other constitutional powers

Control of federal bureaucracy (appointments, retirements; large opportunities for establishing patron-client relations)

State governors with unicameral legislatures subordinate to Federal government through oil revenue distribution

President

Control of federal bureaucracy and para-statal (semi-autonomous institutions) appointments

State governors are elected for six years; each state has a local legislature and has the right to levy state-wide taxes; municipal presidents are elected every three years

state governors and local mayors appoint state bureaucracy

Elected:

President

appoints and supervises cabinet--8 vice-presidents and 22 members--as well as local administrators with approval of Majlis and Assembly of Experts

puts policy proposals to Majlis

local elected councils under supervision of appointed mayor or governor and religious authorities

Unelected:

Council of Guardians

12 members
6 clerics appointed by Rahbar; 6 judges nominated by Supreme Court and approved by Majlis

LEGISLATURE UPPER 

House of Lords

700 members
(600 Life, 75 Hereditary, 25 Bishops)

Symbolic power

Lords may participate in Cabinet

Scrutinizes, delays legislation

Final Court of Appeal

Council of the EU

represents national governments; representation scheduled by COREPER

rotating presidency

initiates all legislation (directives)

qualified majority voting: population and wealth

unanimous vote to overturn rejection by Parliament

Structure:
Supreme Soviet (representation from regional and local soviets)


Function:
General-Secretary

Politburo

Central Committee of CPSU

Federation Council

178 members
five year terms

no formal political parties are allowed

indirect appointment: formerly governors of regions and speakers of regional legislatures appointed themselves to these seats; current law forbids holding dual offices

approves legislation, but negative vote can be overridden by lower house with simple majority

Confirms state of emergency

Structure:
National People's Congress
(3000 representatives from regional and local congresses)


Function:
General-Secretary

Standing Committee of the Politburo
(15 members)

Central Committee of CCP

 

Senate

109 members
4 year terms

increased number of states aims at guaranteeing representation to smaller ethnic groups

reflects tensions between the central government and the states

Senate

128-members
6 year term

96 seats are elected on a first-past-the-post basis, and 32 nationally by proportional representation

Assembly of Experts

86 members
8 year terms

national list

all candidates must be approved by the Guardian Council

appoints and reconfirms Rahbar

reviews, amends, approves, vetoes legislation from Majlis

LOWER

House of Commons

659 members

term at discretion of Prime Minister
5 year maximum

FPTP plurality elections from party list; no residence requirement

Sovereign policy-making power

Vote of No Confidence

European Parliament

732 members

directly elected to 5 year terms

Duma

450 members

term at discretion of Prime Minister, President
5 year maximum

was 1/2 proportional from 2 round run-off party list with 5% cutoff; 1/2 FPTP from districts
as of 2007 proportional from national party list with 7% cutoff and regional membership requirements

Initiates and approves legislation

overrules upper house with simple majority

Vote of No Confidence
-must be passed 2x, then President has power to choose to dissolve or appoint new Prime Minister

House of Representatives

360 members
4 year terms

Tradition of inefficiency and corruption (patron-client relations; regional interests prevail over national priorities)

 Chamber of Deputies

500-members
3 year term

 300 seats are elected on a first-past-the-post basis and 200 by proportional representation

Majlis

290 members

multi-member constituency voting with 25% minimum requirement

all candidates must be approved by the Guardian Council

reviews, amends, votes on legislation proposed by the President which must then be approved by the Upper House, the Council of Guardians, and the Rahbar

JUDICIAL

House of Lords

Common Law

Cannot override acts of Parliament

Conservative

ex-post facto privilege of Prime Minister

European Court of Justice
-one member appointed by each member country for up to 3 6-year terms

Courts of First Instance

Court of Auditors
(finances)

Under the control of the Executive

State Prosecutor; show Trials

People's Courts

Gulags

Supreme Court

19 judges appointed for life by President with approval of Senate

Civil Code

Constitutional Court

Arbitrates between Legislative and Executive

Supreme People's Court

Under the control of the Executive

attempted creation of Civil Code system

State Prosecutor; show Trials

People's Courts

Xia-feng

U.S.-inspired independent judiciary

Common Law

Supreme Court can, in theory, challenge the Executive. In practice, it has not

U.S.-inspired independent judiciary

Civil Code system

There are 68 district courts and a series of appellate courts with a Supreme Court; federal legal system, with states enjoying significant authority

amparos
 

Public Court System Supreme Court; appeals

Revolutionary Court system
no appeals

Clerical Court system
no appeals

Shari'a

all courts appointed and supervised by Rahbar

BUREAUCRACY

Examinations and Elite Educational Institutions

Specialized

Insulated from politics

resist policy initiatives

QUANGOs

COREPER

EU Bureaucracy

Secretariat

Cooption through Nomenklatura

Self-serving

Patron-client

Corrupt

Power Ministries

Nomenklatura
holdovers: siloviki

"shock treatment"

 

Secretariat

Cooption through Nomenklatura

Self-serving

Patron-client

Corrupt

Lack of experience; poorly trained

Bureaucratic recruitment based on ethnicity

Foreign presence (currently, IMF officials in Central Bank)

Federal Election Commission

large opportunities for establishing patron-client relations at local, state, and federal levels

 

highly educated professional bureaucracy increasingly subject to the clergy

Expediency Council
resolves conflicts between Majlis and Guardian Council

Military

Revolutionary Guard

all are appointed by and responsible to the Rahbar

POLITICAL PARTIES

Labour

Conservative

Liberal Democratic Alliance

European People's Party

European Democrats

Party of European Socialists

Communist Party of the Soviet Union United Russia Party

Communist Party of the Russian Federation

Rodina

Liberal Democratic Party

Yabloko

Union of Right Forces

Chinese Communist Party

'Red' vs 'Expert' factionalism

Multi-party system (affiliation mostly determined along ethnic and religious lines)

PDP
(SouthWest)

ANPP
(North)

APGA
(SouthEast)

PAN

PRI

PRD

no official party affiliation is allowed in political campaigns, but factionalism remains:

Second of Khordad
(Reformers)

Servants of the Reconstruction
(Moderates)

Followers of the Imam
(Conservative)

OTHER INTEREST  GROUPS consociational groups:

TUC

CBI

  intelligensia oligarchs

siloviki

nomenklatura

military

youth movements

disorganized pluralist organizations

PLA

CAC

CMC

Falun Gong

Student Democracy Movement

rising wealthy class
(Three Represents)

Communist Youth League

Fifth and Sixth generation of Leadership

The Military

Dominated by Northern groups (Hausa-Fulani)

Despite internal divisions, it is the most cohesive political group in Nigeria

Dominated by patron-client relations between higher and lower ranking officials

increasing lobbying with strengthening of legislature

CTM

CNC

CNOP

Zapatisitas

City Mosques

autonomous semi-public institutionssuch as the Foundation of the Oppressed

the Liberation Movement

the National Front

the Tudeh

Worker's House/Islamic Labor Party

Office of Student Solidarity

Islamic Women's Association

CURRENT ISSUES European Union

immigration

constitutional reform

Northern Ireland

deepening and broadening

immigration

  "vertical power"

relationship with former Soviet countries

Chechnya

corruption and criminal violence

oligarchs

agricultural reform

corruption

income inequity

Taiwan

Market-Leninism

growing nationalism

Dispute of Sharia--fundamentalist Islamic law in North

Rampant corruption

inequitable distribution of oil revenue

corruption

Chiapas

emigration/border control with United States

income inequity

international pressures from national security issues

gender equality

demographic issues: age

 IMPORTANT PERSONALITIES Tony Blair

Gordon Brown

David Cameron

Lord Mandelson

 

Valéry Giscard d'Estaing

Nicholas Sarkozy

Dominique de Villepin

Segolene Royal

 

  Vladimir Putin

Dmitri Medvedev

Yuri Luzkhov

Vladimir Zhirinovsky

Jiang Zemin

Hu Jintao

Wen Jiabao

Xi Jinping

Olesegun Obasanjo

Muhammadu Buhari

 Chukwuemeka Ojukwu

Atiku Abubakar

Ibrahim Babangida

Andre Obrador

Felipe Calderon

Roberto Madrazo

Commandante Zero

Grand Ayatollah Ali Khameini

Mahmoud Ahmadinejad

Imam Mohammad Khatami

Ayatollah Hashemi Rafsanjani

Ayatollah Ahmad Jannati