| |
This week's assignment:
Create an original style of clothing for
American Eagle combining technology and fashion for "wearable technology" --
gadget-friendly clothing. Donald Trump gave each team a $5,000 credit card
to purchase the electronic gadgets. The winning team would be the one that
created the most compelling presentation as judged by two American Eagle
executives.
In the boardroom
Magna won yet again with great ideas
and a well-executed presentation. Net Worth is now on a five-episode
losing streak. They blew it because they couldn't keep track of
anything: Chris lost Trump's credit card (oops), they lost track of
their models, and left behind a key jacket for their presentation. They
also lost track of the time and were almost late for their presentation.
As a result, the severely rattled Angie blew the presentation.
The next day, Chris, Alex and Angie
entered the boardroom and under questioning, Angie admitted that her
presentation was her "worst" showing so far. But she painted a picture of a
hectic and disorganized situation as
the cause. Angie said
she was thrown during the presentation because they had to change the order
of their fashions since they had left a jacket behind. Alex said that
bringing the clothing was Angie's responsibility because she was in charge
of the presentation. Angie shot back that she was in charge of almost
everything. However, Trump got Angie to eventually admit that leaving the
jacket behind was her fault. Carolyn turned her
attention to Chris and asked what he had done. Chris admitted that he had
left the team's credit card at Best Buy and that it was lost for a while.
Angie blamed Chris for the loss and Chris was incredulous. He said that the
team lost because of the presentation, which was Angie's responsibility.
Trump then called Angie and Chris "losers" - they had each been to the
boardroom six weeks in a row. And then he said that Alex, whom he had called
a "star," was now a loser too, dragged down by his new teammates. Trump then
sent the three candidates back into the waiting area to stew.
Carolyn said that Chris
didn't do much and had only excuses. Michelle said that Angie's presentation
was a disaster. After Chris, Alex and Angie returned to the boardroom, Alex
was clear - the team lost because of the presentation, which he said was
ultimately Angie's responsibility. Angie admitted she had turned in her
worst performance to date, but labeled the entire team effort a "fiasco" and
said that Alex couldn't even get his team to the presentation on time. Alex
countered by saying that Angie simply cracked under the pressure. Carolyn
asked Alex what his responsibilities were. He said to oversee everything, to
which Carolyn said, "But everything was pretty much a failure." Trump told
Chris he had been a disaster. He told Alex that he had been brought down by
his two teammates. As for Angie, Trump said that he was bothered by one fact
- that she had choked during the presentation. Trump said he didn't want
someone who chokes under pressure in his organization, and so he said,
"Angie, you're fired."
|
Lessons Learned
Making Effective Presentations
“At one time or another, every manager
will have an opportunity to make an important presentation to peers and
senior executives. How they perform in these situations can
significantly influence the trajectory of their careers. Often
presentation style and personal confidence are as important as the
actual content of the presentation itself.”
-
Do background research.
Become fully conversant, of course, with the subject of your
presentation. But also find out who will be in the audience, why they
are there and what they hope to accomplish. It will enable you to
better target your presentation.
-
Organize your material.
Decide how many points you want to make, then determine how you will
deliver them. For instance, you can make your points in sequence, one
point leading to another. Alternatively, you might want to talk about
a single subject but use a number of subtopics.
-
Use visual aids.
Visual aids help clarify concepts, increase comprehension and increase
retention. Whether you use flip charts, white boards, overhead
transparencies, slides, videos or PowerPoint, keep graphics simple,
colorful and legible. At the same time, keep in mind that you are
center for the presentation, not the visual aids.
-
Verify your arrangements in
advance. Allow time to troubleshoot or
make alternative plans, if necessary. Arrive for your presentation
early to check equipment, cable hookups, access to extension cords,
etc. If you will be using audiovisual aids, have a backup copy on
overheads in the event of incompatible hookups or other technical
problems.
-
Rehearse.
Practice aloud. Practice speaking clearly both in normal tones and at
a higher volume. Become so knowledgeable that you aren’t dependent on
your notes and can add details or adjust to unforeseen developments or
questions during your presentation.
-
Your physical appearance is
your first impression. Your listeners
begin to form impressions of you even before you speak. Be aware of
your hair, glasses, jewelry and clothing. Dress to meet the
expectations of the audience. When something is askew, it draws
attention. So take the keys and coins out of your pockets.
-
Be conscious of facial
expressions. It is pivotal in
communicating your attitude toward your presentation and toward the
audience. It sends an important message about your sincerity and about
your comfort level. Facial expressions can predispose the audience to
listen to what you have to say and even give you the benefit of the
doubt, or it can put people off. So smile.
-
Consider your posture.
Your feet should be slightly apart and your body weight should be
divided equally between them. Your head should be held high and
straight. Your shoulders should be pulled back and level. Your arms
should be relaxed and they should hang by your sides. Your hands
should be relaxed and your fingers should be loose. Your legs should
be straight and your knee joints should be loose—not locked.
-
Speak confidently.
Be authoritative, pausing briefly each time you make an important
point. Use gestures that reflect your words. Maintain eye contact with
your audience, moving your head from one group to another to invite
all to listen.
-
Involve the audience.
If the audience seems bored, use questions to stimulate their
interest. Look for people who are smiling, nodding or leaning forward
in their seats and watching you intently. Make sure that you involve
or engage them in your presentation.
-
Adhere to a time frame.
Know in advance how much time you will need or will be given. Prepare
for 10 percent less than the allotted time. Select in advance
information that can be dropped in the event of a time crunch.
-
Visualize how successful you
will be. Picture an enthusiastic
audience loving every word of your speech to overcome feelings of
insecurity.
PASS
-
Market research.
The dynamic duo of Tana and Kendra again proved their marketing savvy.
They began by visiting an American Eagle store to talk to their target
consumers. They asked them about their ideas and needs for
incorporating technology into their clothing. In contrast, Net Worth
came up with the idea of putting a laptop in the back of a jacket. I
doubt anyone would want to wear an uncomfortable, heavy laptop on
their body. I also doubt they ever talked to their target consumers.
-
Keep them on task.
Tana, Magna's project manager this week, again proved that she is a
leader who can keep her team on task. When tempers began to flare and
the team was becoming dysfunctional, she wisely intervened and
redirected her team by saying emphatically, "We are just going to get
it done."
-
Understanding critical success
factors. Tana wisely recognized that the
presentation would be "one-third of the reason they would win or
lose." Magna delivered their presentation with poise and delivered the
message with clarity, energy and knowledge of the consumer and product
design.
-
When things go wrong --
improvise. Bren and Craig ran into trouble
when they chose a silk-screening vendor who applied some of their
logos backwards and spilled paint on the clothes. Magna kept their
cool and recovered by using White Out on the clothing to patch the
mistakes. OK, so White Out might not have been my first choice, but I
have to give them credit for a creative solution. They bailed
themselves out of a potential disaster. There was no evidence the
executives even noticed the problem.
-
Failure is not an option.
Tana faced a critical decision point when the clothing came back from
the silk screener and was clearly not acceptable for presentation. She
said, "I could cry or I could move on." She chose to move forward to
keep the team motivated. That type of behavior is at the core of
inspired leadership. Trump is looking for a leader who can
handle a challenge and figure out a way around the problem -- going
through it, over it, around it or under it, someone like Tana.
-
Be prepared with the (correct)
answers. Bren had the right answer -- thanks
to Tana and Kendra's market research -- and was prepared when asked by
the American Eagle executive, "What do you think is the most important
technology for the customer?" He responded, without hesitation, "the
cell phone." In contrast, Angie stumbled when asked the same question
and suggested it was the iPod. Do you believe the American Eagle
executives understand which device is more popular with their
customers today? My bet is they do.
FAIL
-
Cool under pressure.
Angie failed to adapt to adversity when her model forgot the key
presentation jacket and got flustered. As a result, her presentation
was dismal. Unexpected situations are part of everyday business and
adversity is often the norm. Effective professionals don't lose their
cool when things go wrong.
-
No preparation.
Angie was ill-prepared for her presentation. It was her responsibility
to ensure the pieces were in place as required for a successful and
professional presentation. Instead, she repeatedly lost her train of
thought, saying "um" continually and fumbling with her notes. Even
junior high students know preparation is the key to delivering an
effective presentation.
-
Resource allocation.
Alex failed to effectively manage his very limited resources in
allowing Chris to waste several hours trying to retrieve the missing
credit card. In today's business world, we are all asked to do more
with less. The key to success is to maximize your available resources
and minimize waste.
-
You are the company you keep.
Trump told Alex, "you hang out with losers, you become a loser."
Successful executives understand that their personnel selections and
team members are critical to business success. Winning is accomplished
with a team that has the necessary leadership, skills and attitude to
win.
-
What's the plan?
An action plan outlining critical items with a timeline is a good idea
for any team project. Net Worth had no excuse for noticing 30 minutes
before they were due downtown for their presentation that their models
were nowhere to be found. Good planning and smart execution would have
avoided this scenario, which ultimately blew their presentation and
any chance of winning.
The Report Card
Net Worth:
- Effort --
- Performance --
- Creativity --
|
D
D
D |
|
| WEEK
ELEVEN |
BOOK SMARTS
Magna
 |
STREET SMARTS
Net Worth
 |
|
|
Magna:
- Effort --
- Performance --
- Creativity --
|
B
B
B |
|
|
|
|