| |
This week's assignment:
Design and sell a commemorative T-shirt
using art from well- known pop artists. The team making the most money
selling shirts wins. Once again the teams were rearranged. Trump
allowed Net Worth's one remaining team member Alex to take Tana from Magna.
In the boardroom
Despite their ongoing conflicts Craig
and Kendra won handily with a creative marketing idea.
Net Worth lost largely because they
wasted time on a trek through Staten Island to buy rhinestones to apply
to the T-shirts. Come on Tana, a sharp girl like you couldn't find
any beads in Manhattan?
Throughout this trek Alex challenged
Tana to address the development of a marketing campaign. Tana instead
was obsessively and exclusively intent on tracking down rhinestones. Her
lack of attention to their marketing campaign resulted in a pathetic
sales effort limited to a sidewalk signboard, Alex street hustling and
Tana gluing beads on shirts. Needless to say, it wasn't a very effective
operation.
After the two candidates sat across from
George and Carolyn, Trump entered and took his seat. Tana told The Donald that Alex had done a decent but not
great job. Alex said Tana was not a good Project Manager - and that she was
terrible at delegating. Alex said the team lost because they sold T-shirts
instead of art. George agreed that the team didn't exploit the fact that
they had a collector's item for sale. Tana had to admit that neither person
on the team thought to market to the art community. But Tana proudly said
that they were able to get nearly $55 dollars a shirt with the rhinestones
on them. But Carolyn said that the team lost their market and spent too much
time on the rhinestones. Trump said it was simple, the team lost because
they weren't as good at marketing as Magna. Tana tried to lay the blame for
that on Alex, saying that he was in charge of marketing. But Alex countered
by saying that no one was in charge of marketing - a statement Trump
wholeheartedly agreed with. Then, Trump dismissed the candidates.
With just his advisors at his
side, Trump asked for input. George said that Alex had fire and Tana didn't.
Carolyn said that she couldn't see Tana working for Trump. Trump agreed,
noting that he deals with "killers" and didn't think Tana could work with
them effectively. After Trump called Tana and Alex back, Alex said that he
tried to discuss marketing with Tana, but she never had the time. Then Alex
said that the team wasted time by going to Staten Island for rhinestones.
Trump couldn't believe that Tana was unable to find the stones she wanted in
Manhattan, the fashion capital of the world. Trump said that the team spent
so much time getting the stones, they didn't have time to sell. Trump told
Tana he sees her as a woman who wants to put beads on shirts and that's not
who he wants to hire. But Tana argued that while she is a nice person, she
has started several successful businesses and has the drive to succeed. Then
Tana added that her record was better than Alex's. Tana said she was Project
Manager three times and had won twice - with one of her victories over Alex.
Trump asked Alex how many times he had lost as Project Manager and Alex said
that he had lost once and won once. But Trump corrected him and said that
Alex had lost twice as Project Manager. Trump couldn't believe that Alex
didn't remember that important fact. Trump turned to Tana and told her that
she had performed terribly on this task, but Trump admitted that over past
weeks Tana had done well. Trump then turned to Alex and said that Tana had
come up with most of the ideas and did most of the selling while Alex seemed
to sit back and hope the team would fail. So, Trump said, "Alex, you're
fired."
|
Lessons Learned
Aligning Sales and Marketing
"Building a cohesive sales and
marketing strategy requires both departments to be on the same page.
Sales should share information from the field, and marketing needs to
share information from research efforts or promotions. In some
companies, these two functions are in the same department. In others,
they may be under different umbrellas. In either case, sales and
marketing must have a symbiotic relationship in order to keep existing
customers and win new ones."
-
Gather critical data.
Qualitative and quantitative research is used
to identify and define markets, develop strategies, test products or
services, float marketing concepts and guide ongoing business
development. It identifies what the customer is thinking, is wanting
and will use.
-
Sift through the facts,
figures and trends. Marketing must
analyze the research data and connect the results to business
decisions. This is used to identify new products or services,
effective marketing strategies and efficient action programs and
activities.
-
Turn analysis into action.
Marketing provides the set of
recommendations that direct specific actions and programs. A strategy
is the basis for integrated plans and varied tactics in support of an
identified and approved business objective.
-
Implement the plan.
This includes creating a tool kit that the
sales department can use. They are developed in concert with the rest
of the company and generally include all elements in the marketing
mix, including print and Web-based collateral, price, promotion and
distribution channels.
-
Provide first-hand customer
insights. Based on their interactions
with current and potential customers, field and telesales reps will
get insights into the products and services of most interest to the
targeted market. Such information should be provided to marketing so
it can include it in promotional material.
-
Share competitive data.
Field and telesales reps often learn before the marketing department
about shortcomings and superior aspects of competitor products. Such
information should be shared not only with marketing—to ensure
promotions touch on the best aspects of the company’s products—but
also to research and development to improve a company’s own products.
-
Identify prime customers.
Sales can help identify demographic and
psychographic commonalities among most likely customers. This will
help marketing create the most effective and efficient messages,
promotions, and media plans.
-
Provide immediate feedback
from customers. Having direct contact
with customers gives field and telesales reps an opportunity to gather
anecdotal compliments, complaints, suggestions and ideas. This
immediate feedback can be taken into account long before the next
round of market research can get under way.
PASS
-
Identify and go after your target
market. Magna wisely sent an e-mail
invitation to more than 3,000 collectors of T-shirt art announcing the
availability of T-shirts they were producing. Kendra recognized that
the artist's fans would be a logical target market for the artist's
work.
-
Be behaviorally specific in times
of challenge. Kendra continually challenged
Craig to provide specific information regarding his constant
objections, challenges and complaints (and lots of whining). She
continued to redirect his rhetoric barrage back at him and requested
specific details about his concerns. Effective leaders help redirect
complainers by requesting behaviorally specific solutions versus
complaints.
-
Sell the value.
Any product that is a limited edition should represent and be marketed
as having more value to the consumer. Both teams marketed their
T-shirts as "limited editions" and identified the works as "art." This
sale was not about T-shirts and both teams demonstrated they
understood the value of their product.
FAIL
-
Inability to resolve conflict.
Craig and Kendra have a relationship pattern of going round and round
with each and getting nowhere. Neither shows respect for the other nor
do either of them have the skills to hold opposing views and still
work together collaboratively. They both tend to blame others (a
common "Apprentice" candidate tendency) instead of taking ownership or
personal responsibility for their part of the issue. Effective leaders
spend maintenance time attending to the way that teams work together.
-
Setting clear roles and
expectations. In the boardroom, neither Alex
nor Tana could agree about who was in charge of marketing. From the
viewer's perspective, we didn't see Tana clearly assign this role to
Alex. It was Tana's responsibility as leader to set clear roles and
expectations.
-
Inaccuracy or misrepresentation
in business will kill you. It is astonishing that Alex failed to recall his true win/loss record when
challenged by Trump. Given Alex's hunger and desire to win, it seemed
hard to believe that he forgot. Possibly his brain drew a blank facing
down Trump's gun barrel! Yet, you would think an attorney would have
come better prepared to win his case. Surely he knew he would have to
defend his record. One thing is for sure; Trump wanted him to
accurately own up to his win/loss record and was indignant when Alex
presented inaccurate information.
-
It isn't over till the fat lady
sings. Alex should have had this one in the
bag but he forgot the most basic of winning strategies -- you must be
prepared, willing and able to fight to the very end of the battle, not
just almost to the end. Preparation for the case is critical.
Alex should be heading to the next episode but instead he stumbled.
Alex lost at the very end on a silly and amateur slip-up -- so close
but yet so far!
The Report Card
Net Worth:
- Effort --
- Performance --
- Creativity --
|
D
D
D |
|
| WEEK
FOURTEEN |
BOOK SMARTS
Magna
 |
STREET SMARTS
Net Worth
 |
|
|
Magna:
- Effort --
- Performance --
- Creativity --
|
B
B
B |
|
|
|
|