| |
This week's assignment:
This episode of "The Apprentice" began
with Donald Trump asking Mosaic to give up one of their members to Apex. The
project manager, Wes, directed Kelly, one of his strongest team members, to
go to Apex. The task for this episode was to design an in-store catalog for
Levi Strauss, with the winning team selected by Levi Strauss' president,
Robert Hanson.
In the boardroom
Apex avoided a fourth loss in a row with
Ivana's innovative concept -- a "dial a fit" fashion wheel focusing on the
"seat." Mosaic lost primarily because Wes let Maria take over his leadership
role and then executed a flawed plan. Trump was not impressed by Maria's
controlling nature and lack of teamwork or Wes' leadership in handling this
problem. In a boardroom first, Trump fired both of them.
During the course of the episode, Trump
offered that advice that one should "never lose your cool unless it's an act
... to scare your employees."
Trump's advice suggests that he is
advocating leadership through intimidation, manipulation and fear. However,
leaders are far
more effective when they motivate by helping others reach their potential
through support, encouragement, coaching and inspiration.
|
Lessons Learned
How to Delegate Successfully
“Delegating tasks is one of the ways that a project manager can draw on
the strengths of the entire team, manage the workload and reduce overall
stress. It is also a way to empower team members. When a manager or
project leader delegates responsibilities to others, he or she demonstrates
a confidence in their abilities and shows the value of and support for their
professional development. Delegating tasks, however, does not free the
manager from the ultimate accountability for the end results.”
-
Set the stage. Meet with your team members and clearly state
the objectives of the project. Be clear about what success will look
like and then determine what will be involved in achieving those
objectives.
-
Get the team involved. Let your team members participate in
determining how to achieve the desired outcome. People are more excited
about doing a project when they are involved in the process.
-
Select the right person for each task. Assess the skills and
capabilities of team members and make assignments based on know-how and
experience. Ask for volunteers for specific assignments and grant the
tasks accordingly.
-
Provide direction.
Provide the right amount of direction based on the developmental needs
of the team members. If they have little “hands-on” experience, provide
enough “how-to” details for them to succeed.
-
Check understanding. One of the reasons for unsuccessful
delegating is a lack of understanding about expectations. To prevent
this, ask the open-ended question, “Can you suggest how you would go
about handling this task?”
-
Set limits of authority. Team members should know how much
discretion they have on how to accomplish their tasks. Make it clear
what authority they have.
-
Maintain control even while delegating. You still need to
monitor the tasks that have been delegated and to continue the
development of your staff to help them exercise their authority well.
-
Know what not to delegate. While there are many project tasks
you can delegate, there are some responsibilities that you can’t:
teambuilding, reprimanding and performance assessments.
-
Manage risks. Partner with your team members to identify
potential obstacles and challenges as well as how to respond to them,
should they occur.
-
Keep in contact. Empower your employees—let them do the work
but agree upon checkpoints along the way so you will know how it’s
going. Don’t hover over the team members; maintain open lines of
communication to know what each one is doing and support them along the
way.
-
Evaluate and reward performance. Address insufficient
performance and reward successes. If you’re not satisfied with the work,
don’t accept it. Continue to work with the team members to ensure they
complete their assignment to both your satisfaction and that of the rest
of the team.
PASS
-
Out-of-the-box marketing.
Ivana came up with an innovative fashion
wheel for Apex, promoting a message that Levis fit real people of all
shapes. It takes team and management skills to be able to recognize a
good idea and to make it work collectively.
-
Motivate by vocalizing confidence
in team members. Wes initiated his
team meeting by communicating his confidence in his team. He stated,
"This is a strong team," and "exactly who I envisioned." Teams are
motivated and inspired when their leaders communicate that they have
confidence and trust in their abilities.
-
When pitching a client, match
their style and culture. Trump arrived
to the client presentation by parading his fiancée in her tight Levi
jeans. Trump revels in showing off his assets but did so in a way that
communicated respect for his client's product and industry. The
winning team showed up suited up in Levi jeans. Andy advocated for the
same strategy but was overruled by Wes.
-
Know when to talk and when to
listen. Andy gets kudos for presenting
the most intelligent leadership lesson of the episode. When Trump
confronted him about being quiet in the presentation, Andy responded
that, as a national debate champion, he had learned "not when to talk,
but when to listen." Good advice. Andy's competitors should be taking
notes.
FAIL
-
Don't steal the applause from
those who deserve it. Ivana came up with the
innovative design concept that won this task. When asked by the client
how they came up with the design, Jen answered and implied that she
had been involved with the design concept -- even though she couldn't
even grasp the idea at the time. This type of dishonest or misleading
behavior results in a loss of trust between team members.
-
Leaders must maintain control and
order. One of the most difficult challenges
that a leader can face is maintaining control of a team, particularly
when one of the team members is trying to commandeer the ship.
Wes, on repeated occasions, allowed
Maria to assume the leadership role. The critical juncture came when
he acquiesced to her angry demand that he "back off" in the photo
shoot. He lost respect and power at that moment. He needed to act
rather than electing to wimp out and do nothing. Blatant disrespect
should not be tolerated by a leader. Wes should have taken Maria aside
and either fired her, redirected her or let her know, in no uncertain
terms, that he was unwilling to let her dictate orders to him or his
team.
-
Conflict will happen, and leaders
must deal with it. Conflict and
differences of opinion will eventually emerge in any team. The
"storming" stage is a long-recognized phase that all teams go through
on their way to "performing." Unfortunately, many leaders deal with it
either by ignoring it or they fail to manage it effectively. The
ability to manage conflict and differences can be a valuable tool to
yield a better solution in a team environment.
Conflict resolution is a learned
skill that leaders need to master if they hope to lead high-performing
teams. Conflict can either derail a team or result in better
performance. Wes demonstrated he had no conflict resolution skills by
allowing Maria and Sandy to go at each other for more than 30 minutes
during a time-critical task.
-
Learning from your mistakes.
Maria's track record for marketing success
was dismal despite her constant self-promotion that she was "the
marketing expert." Wes made a critical mistake by allowing her to take
over the project given that she had blown three mission-critical tasks
on previous episodes: 1.) She failed to get a written bid from the
printer in the Crest episode resulting in overcharges. 2.) She had to
be replaced as the on-air presenter on QVC because of her nervousness
and lack of poise. 3.) She forgot to include the contact phone number
on the e-mail promotion for the bridal salon. This time, Maria blew it
by not playing up the best asset of Levi jeans by not showing off
enough behinds in the catalog. Effective leaders learn from their
mistakes.
-
Leaders need to communicate a
clear decision-making style. Wes never
established his decision-making authority and as a result was unable
to hold onto his power as the leader of Mosaic. Because he failed to
clearly communicate his decision-making style, Maria was able to take
the ball from him and run with it on her own unchecked.
-
There's no crying in business.
Again, another woman on "The Apprentice"
loses control of her emotions in the middle of a team task and cries.
Maria was in tears after her confrontation with Sandy. Emotional
intelligence is the ability to control and deal with our emotions and
the emotions of others. Personal authority, which is at the heart of
leadership, is lost when emotions are out of control.
MAUREEN MORIARTY
SPECIAL TO THE SEATTLE POST-INTELLIGENCER
|
|
|