| |
This week's assignment:
The assigned task was to produce their
own "M-AZING"candy bars at an M&M/Mars production facility and then sell
them on the streets of New York City. The team making the highest profit on
sales of candy bars they produced would be the winner. Mosaic was down to
two members, Sandy and Jennifer M., with Sandy being the project manager.
Apex had three members, led by Ivana with Kelly and Kevin.
In the boardroom
Despite having produced fewer bars -- with
production scenes reminiscent of Lucille Ball on the candy room assembly
line -- Sandy and Jennifer M. won handily, boasting profits of $1,023. They
capitalized on creative sales and pricing strategy to make up for their
production deficit. Their strategy: to have customers buy candy from the
"eye candy" -- they dubbed themselves the "M&M sisters" and wore red tank
tops, short denim skirts -- and to price their candy bars at a whopping $5
per bar.
Donald Trump was impressed with their
teamwork, noting that they "looked like sisters" and that just the week
before they "hated each other."
Apex lost, posting profits of $560 (even
though they produced more bars) with a sales price average of less than $2 a
bar. Trump fired Ivana, citing her dismal 0-and-2 record and her sales
gimmick of -- get this -- flashing her underwear for money. Trump fired Ivana bluntly stating: "You stripped, I am not hiring a stripper."
This
week's episode was a bit disheartening; after firing Ivana, when
Carolyn told Trump "he had no choice," Trump responded back simply with
"She lost all the time." Shouldn't his answer have been
about her dropping her skirt for $20?
The Apprentice should be more about
business savvy, leadership potential, and emotional intelligence than about
any potential as a drama queen or a stripper.
|
Lessons Learned
How to Market a New Product
"New products and services can be the lifeline for any company. Bringing
these products to market, however, can be challenging. To effectively
compete in an increasingly complex and aggressive marketplace, you need to
have a thorough understanding of all the internal and external forces that
will impact the new product's profitability and, ultimately, the
corporation's survival."
It should be clear to all
internal constituents from the outset what the objectives are and what
success will look like.
Know your customers. Be clear about who your customers are and
what they want. Keep in mind that people buy what they want to buy, not
necessarily what they need to buy.
Know your competition. Determine if your competitors have
similar new products or services and how they plan to market them. Adapt
your own marketing efforts accordingly, considering the 4 Ps of
marketing-product, pricing, promotion and place or point of sale.
Customize your marketing strategy. You're product is unique.
Your marketing strategy should be too. With so many marketing variables
to control, you can create a distinctive marketing plan, even in a
crowded marketplace.
Identify your unique selling point. This is the key factor that
enables your product or service to stand out from competitors. The
differentiating claim need not address the most important attribute of
your product, but must be compelling and meaningful. For instance, the
unique selling point of peanut butter could be an unbreakable jar.
Pricing is crucial. Your pricing decisions need to be based on a
combination of your own goals and the pricing strategies of the
competition. In general, with quality being similar, pricing below
competitors will result in high volume and relatively low margin, while
pricing at the high end of the market will yield lower volume but higher
margin.
Sell the experience. Successful marketing fulfills a customer's
hopes, wishes and dreams. Beyond offering a quality product, consider
the customer's total experience. Design your packaging, your product
presentation, your marketing copy and your distribution channel to
enhance the total customer experience.
Reach your market.
Make sure your message reaches potential customers when they are most
likely to be thinking about or buying your product. This may mean using
multiple media channels at different times of the day, month or year,
depending on the product's usage life or purchase cycle.
PASS
-
High-performing team despite
personal differences. Sandy and Jennifer M. were able to put
aside their personal differences in favor of working together as a
team to achieve their business objective. They kept on task and showed
the ability to exercise emotional self-control, despite previous
personal conflict. They worked together creatively and collaboratively
to achieve the goals of their team and won (handily) as a result.
-
Creative sales strategy.
Sandy and Jennifer M. came up with a
creative sales strategy of dressing like twins to promote their M&M
product in the Wall Street district. No one can argue that packaging
sells. They won as a result of their creativity using sex appeal (in
an acceptable fashion) in selling the product at a premium price.
-
Pricing fundamentals.
Pricing effectively is one of the fundamentals of sales and marketing.
Sandy and Jennifer M. understood that, with fewer bars to sell, they
needed to price their product higher to win. The challenge with this
strategy is to create something that the customer is willing to spend
more money to buy. In Sandy and Jennifer M.'s case, it was all in the
presentation. Their presentation was cute, sexy and appealing to both
men and women.
FAIL
-
Lack of dignity, respect and poor
judgment. Ivana stooped to a new low when
she chose to drop her skirt as a sales tactic to sell a candy bar for
$20. Did she honestly think that Trump was going to hire her to lead
one of his companies after she dropped her skirt for $20 on national
television? You simply can't be an effective leader without
consistently displaying dignity and respect, for others and for
yourself. You have to earn respect from a team. How can you possibly
earn respect when you are dropping your clothes to make money? As a
professional woman, I am troubled that some female candidates on "The
Apprentice" have modeled poor judgment, and at times, a complete lack
of respect for themselves and others. We have witnessed several of the
women this season displaying stereotypic female inappropriate behavior
in the workplace. These women have provided a very poor standard and
example for women in business and for the many young women watching
this show. Women are succeeding in boardrooms, corporations and
running their own businesses across America today with traits such as
integrity, emotional and intellectual intelligence and core business
and leadership skills, not by disrespecting themselves and others.
-
A leadership title does not
necessarily equate to leadership.
While Ivana had the position of the leader, that alone was not enough
for her team to be inspired. She led with no process, no boundaries,
no contingency, and an ineffective strategy. To lead effectively
requires offering teams direction, protection, order and inspiration.
Successful leaders communicate decision-making guidelines, goals and
clear expectations to followers. When confronted with her
opponent's superior strategy, Ivana's response was to call them "cheap
hookers" and drop her own skirt to make a sale. As the leader, she
should have gathered her team back to revise a new improved strategy
to compete. Instead, both Kevin and Kelly just stood around watching
Ivana and her desperate attempts to make a sale.
-
Boundaries. Trump's
savvy deputy Carolyn asked Ivana: "Wouldn't you agree, you weren't
selling a candy bar?" There is a fine line between using attractive
men and women who utilize their sex appeal to capture attention and
dropping your skirt for money. Corporations such as Calvin Klein and
Victoria Secret have made tremendous profits by packaging sex appeal.
However, I totally agree with Carolyn's statement that Ivana wasn't
selling a candy bar when she was flashing her panties.
-
Authority.
As team leader for Apex, Ivana failed to establish any
decision-making guidelines or authority boundaries with her team. As a
result, she had no control or authority over Kevin when he elected to
drop his sales price without getting her approval. Ivana's response
was: "I don't know why Kevin undercut the price on his own." Her
response indicates her lack of decision-making authority or
understanding of how vital authority is for team success. Like a
well-run football team, there is no doubt about who is the quarterback
and who makes the play calls. Kevin made a bad play, without regard
for the rest of the team or the leader's consent. The result was
predictable and a safety for the other team.
Leaders should begin with teams by
communicating what decision-making style they will utilize. Leaders
can choose from the primary styles of autocratic, consultative,
delegation, majority vote or consensus. Different styles are more or
less appropriate for different situations. For example, in a crisis,
an autocratic style offers a leader immediate control. Consensus can
be time consuming and challenging to achieve but results in greater
buy-in and commitment from a team. The mistake that many leaders make
is in failing to communicate what decision-making style the team will
use and understanding how critical decisions will be made or enforced.
MAUREEN MORIARTY
SPECIAL TO THE SEATTLE POST-INTELLIGENCER
|
|
|