| |
This week's assignment:
Jennifer and Kelly executed their final
tasks in a finale full of shameless
self-promotion. They both overcame challenges including last-minute power
needs, emcee cancellations, weather and sponsor display issues (who knew a
logo painted on a field would scare polo horses?).
In the boardroom
The final episode was a live broadcast
from Lincoln Center where Trump polled the audience, his most
trusted advisers, and previous candidates--resulting in heavy Kelly
favoritism. Trump still declared it a difficult decision.
In the final boardroom debate, Jennifer's
strengths as a trial lawyer were evident. Trump summed up the strengths and
weaknesses of the two candidates. And finally -- emphasize, finally -- he
pointed to Jennifer and said those dreaded words: "You're fired."
Kelly proved his leadership ability
consistently throughout the season. Although stiff and not overly
personable, he demonstrated maturity, clarity, creativity, as well as
project management and mediation skills. He also had the unique position
of having led and knowing also how to take orders.
As with all managers, Kelly still has
edges to develop. Leaders cannot inspire teams hunched over their
computers; Kelly needs to work on his ability
to inspire and motivate.
There was a wide range of leadership
skill levels in this season of "The Apprentice." Numerous times, it was
difficult to validate Trump's claim that the candidates were the "best
and the brightest" as there was a certain lack of emotional intelligence
-- self-awareness, empathy and conflict resolution skills -- frequently
displayed by most of the candidates.
Overall, the portrayal of professional
women was particularly disheartening. The junior high school behavior
displayed by most of the women was ridiculous.
The good news for Kelly is that he has
won and will now be the Trump Apprentice. The bad news for Kelly is that
he has won and will now be the Trump Apprentice. In the end, Jennifer
may, in fact, be the true winner -- she doesn't have to report to Trump
for work this week.
For those seeking their own boardroom
success, this advice: Seek out a strong leader mentor, be a lifetime
learner taking leadership and business classes, and hire a leadership
coach to give you the edge.
|
Lessons Learned
How to Be a Top-Notch Leader
"Many believe that leaders naturally rise
to the top, while others feel they are developed and groomed. In order to
optimize your own career as a leader, you must be a visionary, a
trailblazer, a strategist, a communicator, a coach, a diplomat and a
politician. AMA has found that the most successful leaders focus on
the big picture as well as operational procedures."
-
Communicate your goals to your people. Define your strategy
and objectives for your staff. If you aren’t clear where you want to get
to, you won’t know it when you get there.
-
Set values for your staff to follow. These values should
reflect the ethical and interpersonal standards with which you expect
your people to abide.
-
Create a climate of open communication and trust at all levels.
Your executives and managers must feel that they can speak honestly to
you-without fear of any consequences. There’s a proverb: "If you think
you’re leading and no one is following you, then you’re only taking a
walk." Your staff won’t follow you wholeheartedly, if they believe they
can’t be up-front with you.
-
Project the image of a leader. You don’t have to look like a
superhero to be a leader, but you should look and sound credible. You
have to appear confident, competent and caring-show that you are sure of
yourself, that you know what you want your people to do, that you care
about your staff and that others can rely on what you say.
-
Listen. Listen for factual and emotional content. Sometimes,
you can learn more about what’s really happening through noting body
language and tone.
-
Focus. Sort out your priorities as well as those of your
organization. Think about which issues critical to your operation will
demand your personal attention. Assign other areas of importance to
those who you trust to handle them well.
-
Be decisive. Make decisions as you go along. Do not let them
accumulate. A backlog of many little decisions can be harder to deal
with than a big and complex one. At the same time, avoid snap decisions.
Move fast on the reversible ones. Reflect more on the non-reversible
ones.
-
Communicate confidence, conviction and enthusiasm. Display
unsinkable optimism in the ability of your organization and its people
to succeed. You want to demonstrate a commitment to your mission and a
belief in your people’s capabilities to achieve it. Root out those with
limiting expectations. Provide the resources your people need to achieve
mutually agreed-on expectations.
-
Motivate staff. You can do this by acknowledging outstanding
work. You can also do this by modeling excellence yourself. If
you’re not performing at a consistently high level, re-examine your
standards. You can’t inspire high performance from others if you don’t
set a good example.
-
Demonstrate initiative. Don’t waste any opportunity you see.
As a leader, you should go out and look for a chance to move your
organization or team ahead. When you see an opportunity, you need to
take it as far as you can. Don’t stop until you have done everything you
can to reap the full benefits.
-
Be willing to take reasonable risks. President John F.
Kennedy said, "There are risks and costs to a program of action, but
they are far less than the long-range risks and costs of comfortable
inaction."
-
Look for trouble. That is, don’t ignore problems. Also
encourage your people to resolve problems when they encounter them.
PASS
-
Results.
At the end of the season, it's the win-lose record that matters.
Results count and records speak. Kelly posted the higher score for the
season -- 10-4 vs. 6-8 for Jennifer.
-
Integrity.
Jennifer has consistently demonstrated integrity more often than not,
including her refusal to get sucked into many of the numerous
mudslinging catfights. She questioned Kelly's integrity in the final
boardroom, noting his whispering behind her back vs. speaking with her
directly, "like a man." I give Kelly credit for integrity in his
final boardroom. On numerous occasions, he refused to rise to the bait
to sling mud. He even went so far as to champion Raj, despite personal
issues with him and knowing that Raj had talked about how much he
disliked Kelly.
-
Emotional self-control in the
face of high stress. Both Jennifer and
Kelly demonstrated calmness and emotional self-control in the midst of
highly stressful situations and factors out of their control. Both
candidates demonstrated much higher emotional intelligence levels than
their competitors throughout the season.
-
Direction and order in chaos.
Both candidates demonstrated their
leadership ability to effectively provide direction and order for
their teams -- even in tough conditions. This is a must for effective
leadership.
-
Conflict resolution skills.
Kelly successfully mediated a conflict
between Raj and Elizabeth when Elizabeth waltzed into the polo
clubhouse declaring herself "dictator Elizabeth." As you might
imagine, this met with resistance. Kelly stepped in and skillfully
mediated a truce by helping them to identify their feelings vs. the
problem. He motivated Elizabeth to admit to her poor choice of words
and asked the team to stop their childish behavior. He reminded them
that they each had a specialty and should be deferring to each other.
Current research indicates that many leaders spend 20 percent or more
of their time dealing with conflict. Research from Eckert College
suggests that the leaders most suitable for promotion are those who
demonstrate conflict-resolution skills. There are simple and effective
conflict resolution models and skills available to learn and classes
on conflict. One book that I recommend is: "Difficult Conversations:
How to Discuss What Matters Most" by Douglas Stone, Bruce Patton,
Sheila Heen and Roger Fisher.
FAIL
-
Delegate smartly.
Jennifer delegated both the coordination with the
NBA and her ambassador role during the event and with Trump. Trump was
left unattended and without an invitation to the VIP reception. There
are some leadership roles that just should not be delegated. Do you
think The Donald wants to be treated as if he is important? Jennifer
blew it and could not defend herself in the boardroom.
-
No inspiration for team.
Raj and Chris' behavior demonstrated that
Kelly failed to inspire his team. Neither of them was bought in nor
was committed to Kelly or his event. While stuffing 400 sponsor gift
bags, Raj told John to throw his trash on the clubhouse floor because
"it pisses off Kelly, and it's fun." Kelly's response was to pray for
good weather and continue punching into his spreadsheet on the
computer. He should have paid more attention to motivating and
inspiring his team.
-
Micromanagement.
Kelly spent too much of his leadership time micromanaging his team.
The result was open rebellion from Raj and John. Intelligent, driven
professionals do not require micromanagement. Leaders need to
determine how much supervision is required of employees, taking into
account experience, motivation and capabilities.
-
Big picture vs. details.
Both candidates fell short here. Jennifer
stayed up all night printing signs on the computer, which could have
been delegated, but she wasn't visible as the ambassador of her event.
Trump didn't appreciate that she didn't kowtow to him during the
event. Had Jennifer taken the big picture view, she would have taken
the gigantic ego of her potential future boss into account.
Effective leaders balance the helicopter view with the details. The
most important person at the event to impress: Trump. Yet when Trump
arrived at his event, Kelly suddenly recalled that he had lost track
of seating details. It was no doubt an embarrassment for Kelly when he
had to show The Donald to dirty and broken seats.
-
Protect your team.
This counts as a pass for Jennifer -- she
sent her team to bed for much-needed sleep while Kelly unnecessarily
kept two of his three people up late. John and Raj didn't need to be
up listening to the frogs and geese half the night waiting for Kelly.
He should have sent them to bed to rejuvenate for the big event.
MAUREEN MORIARTY
SPECIAL TO THE SEATTLE POST-INTELLIGENCER
|
|
|