| |
This week's assignment:
Kendra (Magna) was in charge of
running the Best Buy World Video Game Championships. For team
members, Kendra was saddled with three of her original Book Smarts team --
"scatterbrained" Michael, Danny, and Erin.
Tana (Net Worth) ran the NYC 2012
Athlete Challenge -- an event to promote New York City's bid to host the
2012 Summer Olympics. Tana was assigned three of her original Street Smarts
team members -- "hot-tempered" Brian, Chris, and Kristen.
In the boardroom
Kendra demonstrated her leadership
ability by inspiring her team through the fast-paced challenges of event
management. She understood her priority was to make her sponsors happy
and did so effectively. She led a high-performing team to victory with
an event that largely went off without a hitch. At the end of the day,
all shared hugs and tears.
In sharp contrast, Tana's leadership
performance at the Olympic event surely wouldn't have won any medals. She
inspired rebellion, not teamwork, by continually demeaning her teammates,
calling them "idiots" and shaming them in front of others -- including
sponsors. Tana may have proclaimed herself victorious, but what she
demonstrated in this task was truly ineffective leadership.
With advice from George, Caroline, Bill,
and Kelly, the Donald hired Kendra. She has proved she is bright, has
tremendous marketing savvy, and that she is a capable leader in a tough
environment.
|
Lessons Learned
How to Be a Top-Notch Leader
"Many believe that leaders naturally rise
to the top, while others feel they are developed and groomed. In order to
optimize your own career as a leader, you must be a visionary, a
trailblazer, a strategist, a communicator, a coach, a diplomat and a
politician. The most successful leaders focus on
the big picture as well as operational procedures."
-
Communicate your goals to your people. Define your strategy
and objectives for your staff. If you aren’t clear where you want to get
to, you won’t know it when you get there.
-
Set values for your staff to follow. These values should
reflect the ethical and interpersonal standards with which you expect
your people to abide.
-
Create a climate of open communication and trust at all levels.
Your executives and managers must feel that they can speak honestly to
you-without fear of any consequences. There’s a proverb: "If you think
you’re leading and no one is following you, then you’re only taking a
walk." Your staff won’t follow you wholeheartedly, if they believe they
can’t be up-front with you.
-
Project the image of a leader. You don’t have to look like a
superhero to be a leader, but you should look and sound credible. You
have to appear confident, competent and caring-show that you are sure of
yourself, that you know what you want your people to do, that you care
about your staff and that others can rely on what you say.
-
Listen. Listen for factual and emotional content. Sometimes,
you can learn more about what’s really happening through noting body
language and tone.
-
Focus. Sort out your priorities as well as those of your
organization. Think about which issues critical to your operation will
demand your personal attention. Assign other areas of importance to
those who you trust to handle them well.
-
Be decisive. Make decisions as you go along. Do not let them
accumulate. A backlog of many little decisions can be harder to deal
with than a big and complex one. At the same time, avoid snap decisions.
Move fast on the reversible ones. Reflect more on the non-reversible
ones.
-
Communicate confidence, conviction and enthusiasm. Display
unsinkable optimism in the ability of your organization and its people
to succeed. You want to demonstrate a commitment to your mission and a
belief in your people’s capabilities to achieve it. Root out those with
limiting expectations. Provide the resources your people need to achieve
mutually agreed-on expectations.
-
Motivate staff. You can do this by acknowledging outstanding
work. You can also do this by modeling excellence yourself. If
you’re not performing at a consistently high level, re-examine your
standards. You can’t inspire high performance from others if you don’t
set a good example.
-
Demonstrate initiative. Don’t waste any opportunity you see.
As a leader, you should go out and look for a chance to move your
organization or team ahead. When you see an opportunity, you need to
take it as far as you can. Don’t stop until you have done everything you
can to reap the full benefits.
-
Be willing to take reasonable risks. President John F.
Kennedy said, "There are risks and costs to a program of action, but
they are far less than the long-range risks and costs of comfortable
inaction."
-
Look for trouble. That is, don’t ignore problems. Also
encourage your people to resolve problems when they encounter them.
PASS
-
Inspire your team.
Kendra demonstrated the true mark of a leader: being able to inspire
with structure under stress. Despite tight deadlines and the
complexities associated with managing the event, Kendra's team
performed well because of clear guidance and direction. She inspired
her team by caring about them. Her genuine appreciation at the end of
the task was charming and sincere.
-
Clarity in roles, goals and
expectations. Effective leadership demands
clarity. Kendra rose to the challenge by clearly communicating
specific roles and task expectations to her team. They responded with
little or no apparent infighting about who was supposed to do what by
when. In contrast, Tana's team suffered in chaos because she wasn't
clear about their roles or her expectations.
-
Treat the sponsors (and Trump)
like gold. Kendra wisely understood that her
primary objective in this task was to make her sponsors happy. Despite
initial challenges with the venue, she was able to inspire confidence
and make the sponsor happy by rising to the challenge with great team
performance. She also was wise enough to keep the spotlight on Trump
during the event.
-
Emotional intelligence.
When faced with challenging situations during a high-paced task,
Kendra responded calmly and did not lose sight of the importance of
presenting a professional front to her sponsors and team. She didn't
lose control of her emotions and therefore maintained her personal
authority with her team.
FAIL
-
Failure to inspire and motivate.
Effective leaders motivate their teams by drawing on their strengths,
respecting them and communicating a clear vision with passion. Tana
chose instead to patronize and demean her team. She continually put
down her team to anyone who would listen -- Trump adviser Carolyn
Kepcher and the sponsors included -- referring to them as "stooges"
and "dumb and dumber." People will rise to your positive beliefs about
their abilities and will give you what you expect of them. Leaders
have the ability to create their own reality with teams. Expect the
worst and, guess what, that is typically what you will get.
-
Delegate to those with commitment
and competence. Tana overrelied on a
leadership style of delegation. Delegation can be effective in certain
situations (with proper structure and boundaries) with employees who
have proved they are committed and competent. Tana didn't believe in
Kristen, yet she delegated the major responsibility of the printed
brochure to her. Tana should have insisted on seeing the final copy
(to proof it) before it was sent to the printers. Because she didn't,
she faced a potential disaster with a printed brochure that included
embarrassing details about some of the athletes.
-
Event planning requires attention
to detail. Successful management requires
everyone knowing what they must accomplish by when. Many things can go
wrong -- details, priorities and clear role assignments need to be
tracked via a checklist and schedule. For example, Tana allowed an
Olympic flag processional with U.S. athletes and the governor of New
York to take place without a U.S. flag. The purpose of the event was
to promote New York as the site for the 2012 Olympic games. It's all
about the American flag.
-
Unprofessional behavior with
sponsors. Tana continually was
unprofessional with her sponsors -- the most critical people to be
impressing at the event. She blew off the governor's aide when he
asked her for his schedule. Unbelievably, she told him he would get it
when she got it. When he later voiced concern about the governor not
knowing what he was supposed to be doing, she actually said, "that's
fine" and left the man standing there! She also made several
derogatory remarks about her team to the sponsors. She forgot the old
adage "praise in public and criticize in private." She told one man in
a fit of anger that she wanted to "punch somebody." Now honestly, is
this an emotional profile of someone who Trump is going to send off to
deal with his high-level corporate colleagues and customers? I don't
think so.
-
Blaming everyone else.
Tana failed to take ownership or accountability for her part in
anything that went wrong. At every turn, when something went wrong,
she blamed her team. Great leaders look at their teams as a "we"
effort and do not cast dispersions on the team when things go awry
because of their poor leadership.
The Report Card
MAUREEN MORIARTY
SPECIAL TO THE SEATTLE
POST-INTELLIGENCER
Tana (Net Worth):
- Leadership --
- Performance --
|
A
A
|
|

|
Kendra (Magna):
- Leadership --
- Performance --
|
D
D
|
|
Kendra vs. Tana |
|
|
|